Author Archives: Allison Howard-Berry

Soccer Explains the World

“Football is the opera of the people” -Stafford Heginbotham

Finally, a happy affliction has struck Haiti: World Cup Fever. Since the tournament began last week, Haitians have something to celebrate and they’re doing it with unreserved joy. One and half million people are still living in camps or on the streets, 5 months after the devastating 7.0 magnitude struck Haiti in January. But soccer is bringing people together; cheerful shouting can be heard across Port-au-Prince when the games are broadcast three times each day at 6:30am, 9:30am, and 1:30pm.

Haitians are, by and large, supporting the Brazilian team. It’s hard to miss the thousands of yellow and green Brazilian flags decorating every corner of Port-au-Prince: hanging from the twisted balconies of fallen buildings, decorating cars and utility poles. Across a wide stretch of Port-au-Prince’s central road, Rue de Delmas, fans have gathered thousands of yellow and green plastic bottles and have strung them, criss-crossed, across Delmas like Christmas lights. The Haitian government has teamed up with groups like FimAid International to erect huge viewing screens in the refugee camps. For a little while, at least, displaced Haitians will have the World Cup games to share with each other as a distraction from the grind of daily life.

And in addition to soccer, there’s hockey. Grace Children’s Hospital, where the prototype C2C clinic will arrive on Tuesday, June 22nd, received a special visit several weeks ago from Canadian NHL player, George Laraque. Of Haitian descent, Laraque lifted the spirits of children awaiting treatment at Grace by bringing hockey sticks and playing a demonstration game. It’s wonderful to see that sports, even in the worst of circumstances, can bring a measure of joy to Haitians.

Across campus at Grace Children’s Hospital, workmen have begun land preparation for the C2C clinic. A cash-for-work program has hired 20 local people to level the land on the northwest corner of Grace’s campus, in anticipation of the delivery of C2C’s container clinic.

Stay tuned in the coming days for more progress on-site at Grace, the installation of the C2C clinic, and soccer dispatches from Haiti.

This entry was posted on by Allison Howard-Berry.

This entry was posted on by Allison Howard-Berry.

Presidential Palace

This entry was posted on by Allison Howard-Berry.

Day 4: 1000 Trucks

Following up on yesterday’s meeting with MSH, we met today with Dr. Georges Dubuche, MSH’s Senior Techinical Advisor. Georges brought us to two of their clinics in Port-au-Prince with immediate need for replacement facilities. Of course, immediate need implies severe damage, and the first step is to get MOH permission to hire a demolition crew.

Georges estimates that it will take 1000 trucks 1000 days to clear the rubble in the city, and I’m not convinced that’s hyperbolic. A word on disaster preparedness, which I found interesting: based on historical records, the last earthquake felt in the Port-au-Prince area along the Enriguillo-Plaintain Garden fault was in 1770. At that time, Haiti was still a French colony, and in developing the city after the earthquake, Louis XVI mandated that all buildings were to be constructed of wood (as opposed to concrete blocks). If you look around Haiti today, many of these wooden buildings are still standing. Louis was on to something.

Thirty-two coups and the economy-draining amortization of what in today’s USD would be 21.8 billion in debt to France (which, curiously, the US took to finance the Louisiana Purchase) later, what wasn’t burned (figurative) by politics, was challenged by hurricanes. With the extreme winds and rains, city planners returned to concrete as a primary building material and paid little attention to old building codes. New building norms were set and no one paid much attention to tectonic plates, which was fine…until more than 200 years of built up stress and energy in the earth brought many [concrete] buildings to ground – and with them much of the relative stability the country enjoyed in the last year/two years. Time to rethink building codes. Shipping containers, anyone?

ThisĀ  doesn’t read like very linear thinking, so let’s loop back: I learned all this driving around with Georges. MSH is an impressive organization, a talented and knowledgeable all-local staff with a wealth of contextual knowledge and a commitment to partnership with and capacity building in the public sector. C2C deeply admires and aspires to the bar they’ve set.

MSH’s approach to clinical programming is an “integrated package of primary health.” Interestingly, a few years ago, USAID encouraged quite the opposite: either you did TB or reproductive health or nutrition or sanitation or malaria, etc. MSH recognized the need to integrate these services in a central community-oriented location; rather than working off the expectation that folks would mobilize between locations for their many needs, MSH clinics offer all the primary care a patient needs in one facility.

They keep both electronic and paper records of community outreach and clinical visits. With two doctors, three nurses, six auxiliary nurses (responsible for the health education and home visits), a full lab, and a radio and bullhorn-disseminated public relations campaign, MSH clinics are quite comprehensive in their planning, scope, reach and reporting. They set the bar for clinic-level health delivery, and C2C and the MSH team will be in close touch in the weeks ahead.

YIKES, it just started to downpour. There are so, so many people in tents…

This entry was posted on by Allison Howard-Berry.

"So much depends upon a pink wheelbarrow" (William Carlos Williams wouldn't mind)

This entry was posted on by Allison Howard-Berry.

Day 3: Canape Vert Hospital and Management Sciences for Health

Another day and another opportunity to learn more about disaster relief, the Haitian people, and the organizations that support this country’s journey back from devastation.

C2C’s partner organization, Americares is providing essential medical and health supplies to dozens of organizations (hospitals, clinics, orphanages) that Haitian citizens are counting on to receive treatment and care. The pharmaceutical supply chain in Haiti, like so many systems, was crippled by the earthquake and the provision of medicine and supplies is this environment is an urgent responsibility that Americares’ experienced field staff is fulfilling in an able and timely manner. Drawing on decades of experience, Americares has the know-how, the commitment to local partnerships, and the dedicated staff to fill this critical gap. Three Americares staff members are on the ground here in Port-au-Prince and are coordinating shipments of supplies into the country and then to health facilities in need. They are generous, experienced and well-networked in Haiti and they’ve been able to help C2C to identify potential partnerships and sites for C2C deployment in the coming months. Check out the extraordinary work of Americares at www.americares.org.

The utility of C2C’s model to a disaster relief environment has become especially salient. Firstly, so many critical facilities have been destroyed or damaged and there simply isn’t a structure from which medical personnel can provide services. But in a more nuanced way, C2C’s model is uniquely suited to disaster relief. Tens of thousands of IDPs (internally displaced persons) are without homes, access to food, water, and healthcare. In the immediate aftermath of the quake, improvised IDP camps were established and tents were distributed. While this served the immediate need, there are now camps all over Port-au-Prince. The one we visited yesterday (formerly the site of the Petionville Golf Club) currently has 70,000 people. The difficulty of providing services of any kind to these populations is that government and relief agencies alike are reluctant to make permanent the itinerant community. By building a health center, the community will become more and more fixed at these camp sites and it’s not a long-term solution. Temporary facilities are more appropriate but, unfortunately, with the hurricane and rainy season on the horizon, tented structures won’t withstand the inclement weather. Enter the C2C modular solution. C2C’s units are “semi-permanent” – stable and durable enough to provide the highest quality of care, but ultimately very able to be moved as the need changes.

Today, Kathleen and I met with two important – and very different – organizations: Canape Vert Hospital and Management Sciences for Health. Canape Vert is a private hospital; arguably, one of the best hospitals in Haiti. After the earthquake, Canape Vert immediately began providing free services. Thier hospital was damaged but is functional. A new maternity wing was destroyed and 15 of 47 patient rooms are no longer safe for occupancy. The management board of Canape Vert Hospital is eager to pursue a hybrid approach to health services: to provide high quality care, at a price, to people who can afford it, and to provide the same quality of care for free to people who cannot. Without any revenue for two months, Canape Vert is an unenviable position: they need to go back to charging for service, but they want to retain a mechanism by which indigent patients can receive care. They believe firmly that the quality of care should be equal for both populations, but the financial challenges of making this happen are enormous. The prospect of a hospital like Canape Vert closing its doors would be a terrible loss for Haiti. While their target population isn’t the poorest of the poor, the have a great sense of social responsibility, they maintain the highest standards possible in this environment and, ultimately, they represent progress and a sound future for healthcare in Haiti.

Management Sciences for Health (MSH) has been working in Haiti for years and their over-100 staff members are all Haitian nationals, with the exception of one person. MSH works hand-in-hand with the Haitian Ministry of Health. They did so before the earthquake and they continue to support dozens of MoH services and systems after. Indeed, they’ve ramped up their programming and they are providing urgent support to public sector employees – the Ministry of Health offices were completely destroyed on January 12th. MSH presently supports 147 clinics all over Haiti. There are a number of sites that would be especially appropriate for C2C’s clinic, because the facility was destroyed. We were encouraged and impressed by MSH’s tremendous efforts, their firm commitment to building local capacity, and their deep partnership with the Haitian government.

Our work here this week is to evaluate potential sites for C2C’s prototype clinic – but the need is staggering. C2C’s model is especially well-positioned to meet this need. We will not lack for deployment sites or for meaningful partnerships with local organizations to operationalize the C2C clinic upon arrival in May. The coming months for C2C will see the opening of the clinic doors, but our task is to scale to multiple clinics, to meet a growing need, and to hone our operational model in a sustainable way.

This entry was posted on by Allison Howard-Berry.

IDP Camp at the Petion Ville Club; Run by the US Army

This entry was posted on by Allison Howard-Berry.

Oshkosh in the IDP Camp

This entry was posted on by Allison Howard-Berry.

Day 2: Six Impossible Things

“Why, I’ve sometimes believed six impossible things before breakfast.” – Alice in Wonderland

1) I won’t loose my mind sitting in traffic for half the day

Tuesday began as did yesterday, as will tomorrow and forever: in traffic. We got back to our hotel, Coconut Ville, about twenty minutes ago and estimate that we netted about four hours in gridlock. That’s par for the course in a city where people – too scared to sleep in their homes – have set up tents in the streets.

For sanity’s sake, you adopt the disposition of your driver – in this case, the curious Valery. Say, for example, someone cuts Valery off or he thinks they’ve made a driving faux pas: he’ll pull up beside them, roll down his window and say something to the effect of, “I feel sad when you don’t let me merge,” or, “I would prefer if you’d use your turn signals.” It’s like couples therapy. The guy next to us will laugh and give Valery a thumbs-up, Valery will shoot one back and then shrug to Allison and me, “I have to teach.”

Valery also gave us a Haitian’s History of Haiti and a personal account of January 12 [the earthquake]. The lectures were complicated/authentic and impossible to wrap my head around, respectively. All told, it was an education in patience and reality and not a bad way to spend four hours.

2) I will make Allison’s “Favorite Stories from Abroad” list

Our first meeting on today’s docket was up in Petion Ville with Save the Children. Save’s providing healthcare at 47 sites in Haiti, concentrated in Port-au-Prince and Jacmel, and they’re interested in replacing/augmenting their use of HousAlls (pre-fab clinical spaces made of what looks and feels a lot like posterboard and would be totally wrecked by strong winds) with the C2C clinic.

Save’s headquarters in Petion Ville is quite the establishment, and we had to check in with a cadre of security guards before entering the building. They asked for I.D. at the gate, so Allison whipped out her passport, a guy looked at it for a hot minute, found the information he was looking for and wrote in his book: “Howard, Allison.” All set.

The first thing I’d fished out of my bag was my wallet, so I handed the guard my New York State Driver’s License. The guy stared at my I.D. for a good 90 seconds and then, with furrowed brow and much deliberation, began writing in all caps “O” “R” “G” “A” “N” -space – “D” “O” “N” – at which point I – reading the thing upside down – totally lost it to giggles and Allison guffawed: “ORGAN DONOR?!” Recognizing nothing about my license, the security guard had decided that my name would be written in the boldest, most obvious text, which in the case of my NY State I.D. is “ORGAN DONOR.” In any event, we explained it to the whole security team, everyone had a good laugh, and I will forever be known as “Organ” by the security detail at the Save headquarters.

The meeting itself went well; we’re waiting to hear back from the Director of Health and Nutrition about a few site visits later this week. More detail to follow.

3) I will meet a movie star in Port-au-Prince

We wrapped the day at the weekly Health Cluster meeting at the UN compound, which abuts the airport and is a stone’s throw from a massive U.S. Army operation. The WHO [World Health Organization] is coordinating all health-related activities in Haiti, and they have weekly meetings to assemble all the players, download everyone’s information (shared best practices), and act as conduit between the Ministry of Health and health-focused NGOs.

This last piece is quite the task, especially when you consider the host of what seasoned folk here call “cowboy NGOs.” Speaking of cowboys, Sean Pean was at the meeting. Wait, what? Yes, seriously. Sean Penn apparently has a foundation that’s running a “hospital” (read: tent. Everything here is semi-permanent/temporary) at what I’m told is the largest IDP [internally displaced persons] camp in PAP. The camp is one of many “spontaneous” camps that people migrated to after the earthquake. This one is home to about 70,000 who took refuge on Petion-Ville Club’s golf course. I’m sure the owners of this swanky private club are pleased; with 70,000 people, spontaneous or otherwise, this camp will squat on the golf course for a while. Which brings me to my next point:

4) Children can still be children in IDP camps

Allison and I, fascinated by everything we’d heard about the camp and with a professional interest in seeing Save’s HousAll structures in action, decided to check it out earlier this afternoon (note: in addition to the Sean Penn Hospital, Save’s operating a two-unit HousAll primary care clinic in the camp).

The PV (Petion Ville) camp is unlike anything either of us has ever seen. Imagine it’s 95 degrees, there’s no shade, little in the way of sanitation control, blue and orange tarps as far as you can see one right on top of the other, people pushing each other up and down narrow paths in the steep camp side (an IDP camp built into a hillside – not a super decision considering uphill latrines and the impending rainy season…), and hundreds upon hundreds lined up front-to-back to collect food rations. People were just absolutely EVERYWHERE, without schools or jobs or music or dancing and who will for the foreseeable future be focused “simply” on survival.

And yet, their children smile. At first, they were totally skeptical of two weirdo random ladies loitering around, peeking into the clinic (which, by the way, seemed to be operating well and for the primary benefit of women and children) and scratching their heads. But, for a camera, what child won’t smile? What kid isn’t going to giggle and run away, come back, giggle and run away when he sees his face played back to him on my camera screen? Maybe he didn’t even know what he was looking at, but it was fantastical and he was curious and he smiled. He’s a kid. Even in an IDP camp, thank god a kid can smile.

5) Healthcare can be administered from inside a topless bar

This is a brief return to Monday’s expedition to Petite Goave. Fact: IMC is operating their primary care clinic from an abandoned topless bar on the beach. Central, spacious, shady, it’s everything they need. Of course, the naked women painted on the walls, the tarp room dividers, and the five feet to the water aren’t ideal, hence their interest in the C2C clinic.

This is something we’ve seen a lot of in the past two days: organizations and people not letting “perfect” be the enemy of the good; rather, they’ve optimized what’s available -whether that’s tents, overheated HousAlls, or abandoned topless bars. Still, two months out from the earthquake, everyone’s a bit tired of the obvious limitations of these spaces for use as sustainable health structures, and a C2C clinic presents like a godsend. There’s a clear need for the stability and adaptability of C2C clinics all over the country. Scaling the model here poses interesting questions, but now I’m getting ahead of myself, so let’s just leave it there. The take-away is simply: Yes, healthcare and provocative wall art can cohabit.

6) I will survive a week of eating only Clif bars and fried plantains

So far so good

This entry was posted on by Allison Howard-Berry.

Chowing down at an Order of Malta Clinic in Leogane

This entry was posted on by Allison Howard-Berry.